Wednesday, July 11, 2007

The Use of Dogs for Cell Extractions in U.S. Prisons

The use of dogs to threaten and attack prisoners to facilitate cell extractions has been a well-kept secret, even in the world of corrections. The dogs used for cell extractions typically are German Shepherds or Belgian Malinois—both large breeds of dog that usually weigh well over sixty pounds and stand over two feet high. When a handler and his dog enter a cell block in connection with a possible cell extraction, the dog barks loudly and continuously, jumping up against the cell door and scratching at the window. If the prisoner continues to resist, he knows the dog will be loosed on him. Some prisoners will wrap blankets, towels, and even toilet paper around their limbs to try to protect themselves from dog bites. When the guards open the cell door, the leashed dog enters the cell first. The dog is trained to bite whatever part of the prisoner it can grasp first.
I think that using a dog as a tool to make a person to obey is not right. The prisoners would rather get bitten by a person than a dog. Do they have to bitten by the dogs whenever they resist? The dogs would probably does not know what they are doing and I do not think that they are wrong. The people who use the dogs to take advantages for them are wrong.

4 comments:

Chris Lee said...

What exactly is a cell extraction? To get a prisonor out of jail to go into the yard or what?

Regardless,
I don't think dogs should be used for cell extractions unless the prisonor is threatening the guard. Most people are scared of German Shepherds biting them, which, I can see is a good reason dogs are being used, but it is cruel and unusual punishment if they aren't doing anything wrong.

kate_mcg said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
kate_mcg said...

It confuses me why we substitute animals in to do the dirty work. Whatever happened to people doing their own jobs?
It's not an appropriate way to make this kind of situation into a catalyst. This also applies as cruel and unusual punishment to the inmates.

Anonymous said...

i think it is alright to use dogs but even though the dog is well-trained what if something bad happens.